Sisters and Brothers,
We have been meaning to get this out to you
so that you can have a picture of where the legal case stands now.
We urge you to call Judge Massiah-Jackson ASAP as she still has
the power to reject Judge Dembe's rulings, and that would be great
news!
Phone: (215) 686-2523 Fax: (215) 567 7328
THE MURDER OF FRANCES NEWTON SIGNALS DANGER
FOR MUMIA ABU-JAMAL
(to download this in a word file, please
visit http://www.freemumia.com/legalupdateoct2005.doc
The recent killing of Frances Newton is a
reminder that the death penalty is still intact and with the
appointment of a pro-death penalty Chief Justice of the Supreme
Court a major threat to Mumia.
In February of this year the Pennsylvania
state courts continued their refusal to consider any evidence of
Mumia's innocence, or the extensive documentation of police,
prosecutorial, and judicial misconduct regarding what happened on
December 9th 1981. Court of Common Pleas Judge Pamela Pryor Dembe
ruled against hearing affidavits by Yvette Williams and Kenneth
Pate. Williams had sworn that star prosecution witness Cynthia
White had told her she had lied at Mumia's trial. Pate had sworn
that his sister-in-law, Priscilla Durham, a hospital security
guard, had told him that she also had lied at Mumia's trial when
she corroborated the cops' two-months-delayed story about Mumia
confessing while lying on the hospital floor.
Dembe had previously excluded the affidavit
of Terri Maurer-Carter from the legal record. Maurer-Carter, a
long-time court reporter, had sworn that she had overheard trial
judge Albert Sabo vow outside the courtroom that he was going to
help the prosecution fry the nigger'.
Dembe ruled that even if true, she found no
evidence that such a sentiment had affected Sabo's trial rulings!
Significantly, the sworn confession of Arnold
Beverly that it was he, and NOT Mumia, who had killed Officer
Faulkner, along with several other affidavits including a former
FBI agent who supported Beverly's version of what was behind this
killing, were also excluded from the record.
Besides Sabo's alleged stated determination
to convict and execute Mumia, referring to him as a
"nigger", he still holds the dubious distinction of
having sentenced more people to death than any other judge in
modern times, and of those 31 only two were of European ancestry.
Though Sabo died four years ago, it is his
extremely unfair and racist record, severely criticized by Amnesty
International and dozens of legal bodies in this country and
around the world that has been rubberstamped by Judge Dembe.
Almost simultaneously with Dembe's last
denial of a hearing, some major death penalty decisions in other
courts provided hope as important precedents and decisions that
were potentially applicable to Mumia's case came down. The hopes
in Mumia's situation had been based on three cases. Two involved
Thomas Miller-El, who was sentenced to death for a 1985 murder in
Texas.
The U.S. Supreme Court ruled in these cases
that:
(1) Miller-El's constitutional rights had
been violated when prosecutors used peremptory challenges to
strike 10 of 11 prospective Black jurors;
(2) that the courts--the federal Fifth
Circuit in particular--have unreasonably interpreted the
Anti-terrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act (AEDPA) of 1996 to
make it virtually impossible for a death row prisoner to pursue an
appeal in the federal courts.
Both of Miller-El's cases apply directly to
Mumia's, in which the District Attorney's office used peremptory
challenges to eliminate 11 of 14 prospective Black jurors in a
city which at that time was 40% Black.
Moreover, the federal judge who considered
Mumia's habeas corpus appeal threw out 28 of 29 constitutional
claims based on the now-discredited interpretations of the AEDPA.
In the third case, House v. Bell, the Supreme Court agreed in June
to reconsider its almost impossibly high standard for reopening
death penalty cases based on claims of innocence. This was a major
challenge to the Herrera decision which ruled out innocence as a
justification for a new trial in cases where due process was
supposedly adhered to. Only last week, in the Senate's hearings
about his nomination to become Chief Justice of the Supreme Court,
John Roberts, supported the Herrera decision as being a reasonable
one. The decision also challenged the AEDPA which has been the law
of the land on the limited right to appeal death penalty cases.
There seemed to be a real opening for the possibility of a new
trial for Mumia based on these decisions alone.
But now with the recent, court-approved legal
lynching of Frances Newton by the state of Texas a flood of
ice-water has dashed these hopes, once again swinging the pendulum
in the other direction. Despite compelling
new evidence pointing to her innocence, despite
appeals by a former U.S. Attorney General, the current president
of the American Bar Association, the Texas Publishers Association
and the principal newspaper in the state capital, among others, no
court deemed it necessary to stay her execution.
For us the lesson should be clear: it doesn't
matter to the authorities what the truth is--they killed Frances
Newton to assert their supposed right to execute whomever they
want and, by extension, to terrorize all of us into accepting
their control. Yet the truth is that they are far more vulnerable
than they seem, and far less powerful too. Their catastrophic
failures in both Gulfs have revealed their callousness, racism,
and incompetence to millions around the world and in this country.
Similarly, their inability for 23 years to execute Mumia, despite
their absolute commitment to doing so and their repeated
statements that they would succeed, all reveal that, in the end,
they cannot ignore the will of the people. We refuse to accept
this government's attempt to discourage, frighten, and intimidate
us.
We must watch every move they make in the
courts, take advantage of every window of opportunity and, at the
same time, build a movement still stronger to fight the US
occupations, the injustice, AND TO FREE MUMIA AND ALL OUR
POLITICAL PRISONERS!
Written by the Free Mumia Abu-Jamal Coalition
(NYC),
October 2005
JOIN THE STRUGGLE TO FREE MUMIA AND ALL
POLITICAL PRISONERS!
NEW YORK FREE MUMIA ABU-JAMAL COALITION (212)
330-8029 (Hotline)
Website: www.freemumia.com
INTERNATIONAL CONCERNED FAMILY AND FRIENDS OF
MUMIA ABU-JAMAL
(215) 476-8812
Website: www.mumia.org
To make much needed contributions, please
call these numbers or check the websites.
Call Judge Frederica A. Massiah-Jackson,
Pamela Dembe's supervisor, to let her know you are outraged by
Judge Dembe's decisions. (215) 686-2523 OR FAX HER: (215) 567 7328
***************************************************
I want to know what sustains you from the
inside when all else falls away. ~ Oriah Mountain Dreamer~
***************************************************